Revolutionizing Control Systems: Bridging Classical Techniques and Modern Innovations
By Bathlomew Amaka Ebika
Control systems have been the cornerstone of technological progress, grounded in classical techniques such as Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controllers and state-space models. These methods have provided stability, optimization, and safety across diverse industries, from simple mechanical devices to complex industrial processes. However, as the pace of technological advancement accelerates, so too do the challenges facing control systems. This article explores the emerging challenges, particularly in manufacturing and biomedical engineering, while discussing the necessity for innovative approaches that blend classical techniques with modern advancements.
Classical control techniques have long served as the bedrock of effective system management, especially in environments where the dynamics are well understood and relatively straightforward. PID controllers, for instance, have become standard in numerous applications due to their simplicity and proven effectiveness. Likewise, state-space models have enabled engineers to mathematically represent complex systems, allowing for the design of more advanced control strategies. Over time, these classical methods have evolved to handle increasingly intricate systems. Adaptive control techniques, which adjust system parameters in real-time based on performance feedback, exemplify this evolution, as do robust control methods designed to maintain stability even amidst uncertainty. These adaptations underscore the flexibility and enduring relevance of classical control approaches in meeting new demands. However, the landscape of control systems is rapidly evolving. The rise of the Internet of Things (IoT), artificial intelligence (AI), and the expanding importance of biomedical applications are challenging the limits of what traditional techniques can achieve. While classical methods remain invaluable, they increasingly need to be augmented by modern approaches to address the multifaceted and complex challenges that characterize contemporary systems.
READ ALSO: Nigerian Innovator Bathlomew Ebika Earns US National Interest Waiver
The past two decades have seen the emergence of challenges that were not fully anticipated by classical control techniques. For instance, the rise of interconnected systems has introduced significant cybersecurity vulnerabilities. Protecting critical infrastructure such as power grids, water supply systems, and medical devices now requires advanced control strategies capable of detecting and responding to malicious activities in real-time. The infamous Stuxnet attack on industrial control systems serves as a stark reminder of the urgency for enhanced advanced cybersecurity measures. The integration of AI and machine learning into control systems has opened new possibilities for predictive maintenance, optimization, and autonomous decision- making. These technologies also demand the processing of large volumes of data and the ability to adapt to complex, nonlinear dynamics—challenges that traditional control techniques are not fully equipped to manage. Autonomous vehicles, which rely on AI-driven control systems to make split-second decisions based on real-time data, highlight the complexities involved. Furthermore, the deployment of AI-driven control systems in healthcare raises ethical and regulatory concerns, particularly around issues of accountability, transparency, and patient safety. Ensuring that AI in clinical decision-making is carefully regulated to protect patient outcomes exemplifies the broader challenges facing control systems development in the health sector today.
In the field of biomedical engineering, biotechnology, and medicine, the limitations of traditional control systems are becoming increasingly apparent, particularly as the demands of modern research and development push the boundaries of these systems. One significant challenge lies in neuroengineering, where precise modulation of neural activity for therapeutic purposes, such as in deep brain stimulation or spinal cord stimulation, requires control systems that can handle the nonlinear and time-varying nature of neural responses. Traditional control methods often struggle with the unpredictability and variability inherent in neural signals. To address this, a combination of traditional control approaches with advanced techniques like adaptive control and machine learning is crucial, enabling real-time adjustments based on individual patient responses and neural dynamics. Similarly, bioelectronic medicine presents its own set of challenges. Implantable devices designed to interface with biological tissues must do so without causing adverse reactions or degrading over time. For devices used in chronic pain management or epilepsy treatment, maintaining precise control over electrical stimulation parameters is essential. Traditional control systems must be complemented with advanced methods to ensure long-term stability and reliability, while also adapting to the dynamic biological environment. In the realm of personalized medicine, drug delivery systems such as smart insulin pumps or automated chemotherapy infusers need to adjust dosing based on real-time patient data, which can be highly variable. Here, a hybrid control approach integrating traditional feedback control with sophisticated real-time adaptation algorithms can ensure that these systems are both precise and responsive to individual patient needs. Combining traditional control techniques with advanced models, such as neural networks and fuzzy logic, can enhance the handling of process dynamics and uncertainties, leading to better control and process optimization. Wearable health devices, like continuous glucose monitors or cardiac monitors, require control systems that strike a balance between accuracy, reliability, and energy efficiency.
In one of my research studies titled “Development and Optimization of Predictive Models in Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) Using Machine Learning Approach,”a hybrid approach combining traditional and advanced control techniques was employed to optimize the WAAM process. Classical control techniques, such as Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controller, were used to manage fundamental parameters like voltage, wire feed speed (WFS), and travel speed. These methods ensured stable control over these basic process variables, maintaining them within desired ranges to achieve consistent bead quality. To further refine the process, modern control techniques, particularly Gradient Boosting Regression Modeling (GBRM) were integrated. GBRM, an advanced machine learning technique, was utilized to analyze feedback and historical data, providing predictive insights into process parameters such as voltage, travel speed, wire feed speed, and Contact Tip to Work Distance (CTWD). By combining the stability provided by classical PID controllers with the dynamic optimization capabilities of GBRM, the research achieved enhanced bead geometry and improved process efficiency. This integration demonstrated how traditional control methods can be effectively augmented with modern predictive models to achieve superior manufacturing outcomes.
In summary, the integration of classical and modern control techniques signifies a transformative approach to tackling the complexities of contemporary systems. Classical control methods, such as Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controllers and state-space models, have long been celebrated for their simplicity and reliability. These techniques provide a solid foundation for managing well-understood system dynamics and ensuring stable, predictable behavior. Their proven effectiveness in various applications—ranging from industrial processes to everyday devices—underscores their enduring value. However, the rapid advancement of technology and the increasing complexity of modern systems have highlighted the limitations of traditional methods when faced with new challenges. The rise of interconnected systems, big data, and advanced technologies like artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning has introduced new dimensions of complexity that classical techniques alone struggle to address. To bridge this gap, modern innovations bring adaptability, predictive capabilities, and real-time responsiveness that classical methods lack. For example, machine learning algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data to forecast system behavior, optimize performance, and adapt to dynamic conditions, while advanced techniques like Gradient Boosting Regression Modeling can fine-tune process parameters with high precision. The synergy between classical and modern control approaches leverages the strengths of both methodologies. Classical techniques provide the stability and robustness required for fundamental system management, while modern techniques offer advanced capabilities for handling complex, nonlinear dynamics and optimizing performance based on real-time data. This hybrid approach not only enhances system performance but also addresses emerging challenges across diverse fields such as manufacturing, biomedical engineering, and cybersecurity. By blending the reliability of traditional methods with the innovation of modern technologies, this collaborative framework sets the stage for future advancements in control systems, driving progress and efficiency in increasingly sophisticated environments.
Author: Bathlomew Amaka Ebika, B.Eng, MSc, R.Eng, NSE, MIEEE, MISA, Co-Investigator-NASA USRC 2023, NSF-HAMMER Researcher, Engineer 1-Biomedical Engineering – Case Western Reserve University, United States National Interest Waiver (NIW) Recipient-Exceptional Ability-USCIS, TÜV Certified, KHDA Certified, Founder and Pioneer-Gifted People Network (GPN).
